Here is the last article I am writing for inclusion in the next version of the Pentel Pencil Identification Book. Along with the “Possible Release Order of Early Pentel Stick Pencils” and “Types and Generations of the Pentel Eleven”, this new article “Generational Changes to the S5x Series” will be included.
I also some that may be gen 2 but have the sharper grip like the gen 1 S5x pencils. These have the 4mm tip thread. In fact, without removing the tip it is not at all easy to tell gen 1 from gen 2 pencils.
We know that Pentel never threw anything away so there is likely some blurring of the generations.