The Knips/Belfor-Clicker sideknock-pencil and the search for the first sideknock

A “side-knock” pencil is a pencil whose lead is propelled by a push on the side of its body.


I would like to expand on the following great resources from fellow Knockology members:

Patrick from Great Mechanical Pencils: Pentel Technica: The World’s First Side-Knock pencil?
Alan aka. graphography: Mechanical Pencil Month – Day 11: Side-knock pencils


On the term “side-knock”

This term is owed to the japanese influence on pencil terminology in the 2nd half of the 20th century, where “knock” caught on to express “push-actuated”.

Taking pencils predating mentioned timeframe into account, one could also call it ‘barrel squeeze’ or any other not yet established term better fitting to describe its method of propelling the lead.


As Patrick mentions in his video, Pentel possibly claimed false credit attributing the invention of side-knock pencils to itself, taking the title of first side-knock from the Mitsubishi Pecker.
Looking at an previous injustice by Pentel, as another Knockology member Drifand notes in the comments, strengthens this suspicion.

The mechanism is simple to understand (image taken from Alan’s website):


But Alan points out an earlier pencil in his blog: The Belfor Clicker from England.

Its original name is KNIPS, invented in Germany in 1932 by Heinrich Jöhnßen in Nürnberg. The patent is DE598358 (english here). Note that the patent is my own research and has no official confirmation.

The name Knips is likely originating from the homonymous onomatopoeia for a button click in German.


How the KNIPS works

It’s a two-sided ratchet mechanism whose teeth are offset by half a tooth’s width. The teeth are connected to the push rod.

The teeth-push-rod-piece is acted upon with a forward force by a spring.
It is hindered from expelling the lead all on its own by a detent grabbing into the teeth:

The “button” is really one long piece carrying a plate that has a cut-out to engage with the teeth in alternating order. A detent on either side.

Now it should be apparent that pushing the protruding button inwards lifts the still engaged detent up, enabling the tooth rack to travel forward (by spring force only) until the former detent finally catches its respective tooth.

Jöhnßen improves on it in 1936 in DE632163 using a bolt which travels along the tooth rack in an inversed manner:


How do you retract the lead?

As it is with ratchet mechanisms, the geometry of the teeth blocks movement in one direction and allows it in the opposite.
A push to the tip, overcoming the spring tension, therefore, should make it retract.

Despite what the german patent and instructions say (they tell you to hold the pencil vertically), orientation should not matter (could someone verify?). In the later english patent and Belfor Clicker instructions, that specification was indeed left out.


Who manufactured the Knips?

While the Belfor was made in England, the Knips was made in Germany by Rakete and, confusingly, also distributed in the British Empire in 1934.

Rakete was founded sometime before 1925 in Beerfelden, Hessen by Kurt Meißner.

Hence, there exist Knips-identical pencil models “Rakete 123” and “Rakete 456”, both also called Rakete-Schnappstift.

More information on Meißner, Rakete and the later-acquired “Columbus” can be found here but it’s not a lot and more about fountain pens.


I hope you found it interesting.
Edits are spelling mistake corrections.

Kind regards
Mathis

20 Likes

I managed to get one recently from a seller in England. It’s a difficult one to track down. Very interesting the back and forth button push mechanism to advance the lead.

4 Likes

I have a couple of Belfor Clickers and I cherish them dearly.

5 Likes

Without the Belfor, there may have never been a Knockology! Who knows!?!

4 Likes

:100:

4 Likes

The idea of Mitsubishi having a side-knock Pecker patent in 1913 really raises my eyebrows. Regardless of date or claims to originality, seeing the small push-buttons on the old specimens in this post made me realize that ‘Pecker’ is in reference to woodpecker, tapping away at the sides of a tree.

I suppose this name-origin has been discussed many times and I am just slow.

Lovely celluloid work:

3 Likes

Mitsubishi cited the patent in their Pecker patent, the 1913 one is not by Mitsubishi of course

3 Likes

Mine is simply black. Those are beautiful

2 Likes

Some lovely documentation in this thread. I can take it back a little further, perhaps, if these examples count, to 1882, as the paper patent I found after much searching dates this design.
This is a pair of circa 1880 side knock (or ‘barrel squeeze’!?) pencils I found a few years ago, by… L&C Hardtmuth.
One of the pencils is solid silver and unmarked, presumably a test model worked up by a silversmith before the manufacture model was made? These take a 2.5mm leadrefill, a size still used by Hardtmuth today and the mechanism is designed to express a little more lead each time the bowed cage is pinched. It’s such an elaborate and ingenious design.





,

10 Likes

Well, that is almost certainly the earliest candidate for a side-knock pencil I have seen, if not the most unusual! It seems strange that the design is not better known, especially coming from a major maker like Hardtmuth. I can only imagine that the mechanism was too fiddly and liable to get out of order.

On the subject of early side knocks, I"m still hopeful that a specimen of Freeman’s 1844 ever-pointed pencil will come to light some day.

2 Likes

Oh these are really cool!

1 Like

Thanks for sharing.

express a little more lead each time the bowed cage is pinched

Does the lead not fall out when pointed perfectly vertical?
At least according to the patent, I’d call it a “side-clutch”: pecker and knips in contrast both have incremental feed, which always seemed like a requirement for “knock”-pencils to me

1 Like

No, the lead remains held when upright, even with the cage squeezed, by friction of the locked foremost metal sleeve. Squeezing the cage disengages that sleeve and engages a second sleeve with shims, to further grip and push a length of lead out a little, incrementally, as it were, then when released the initial sleeve re-engages to hold the lead for use. The nearest thing I have seen is tge mechanism on the Lyra Klimax, shown here- Name that PENCIL or PEN [8] - #26 by TheGoodPhite that us used to push andcretract the whole mechanism- a similar era so perhaps gave Hardtmuth the idea!?

Heres the description of these pencils action, fom the US patent (Hardtmuth, 1 may 1883, no. 276,812)

1 Like

That’s neat, the german one doesn’t even have a summary.

But doesn’t the part that you quote perfectly describe a clutch pencil?
“again securely held” implies there was no secure hold while it was pressed.

The American patent gives much more info, but at the same time adds additional components, it is an improved variant.

1 Like

Huh, looking now, I see you are absolutely correct- my interpretation comes from looking down the nose apperture on the actual pencil, where I can see the shims move back and forth- and with lead in place, when you release the cage, these shims carry the lead itself forward a small but consistent amount then grip it- repeatedly so- hence my ‘incremental’ claim… perhaps I am assuming it is held when released only because it does not fall out- it may be only the nose aperture is gripping the lead- maybe its set for 2.4mm leads and I have a 2.5mm lead in there…? Quite possible- I’ll have another look, but I stand corrected, without taking it apart! (always such a risk with these older examples, even with reassurance from the patent!)

I modeled the one seen in the german patent, the american one is a bit more complicated

8 Likes

Holy mother of Hardtmuth… Amazing!!!