My Mystery Machine: rOtring '500' lead holder


About 10 years ago, before the Ukraine war started, there was a very interesting Russian called Andrey who ran an eBay store, filled with tons of vintage mechanical pencils. I think I caught my first glimpses of Colleen Jib w-knocks, along with Newman drafters there. And amongst Andrey’s wares, the one that I felt was truly ‘Unobtanium’ was this listing for a ‘Vintage rOtring 500 2mm Drafting Leadholder 1980s’. It had the same burgundy red plastic body as the original 503/505/507 pencils but… it did not bear the ‘500’ marking. Most of all, it was priced at a king’s ransom of 2000 USD… a sum my then 5000-yen limited brain could not comprehend.

I have shared my thoughts on this ‘unnamed model’ in the past: that it felt like something so new for rOtring that they had not yet decided on a proper model number for it. Because, if the 500-series was properly planned, then the 2mm lead holder would probably be called the ‘520’ to fit into the 50X naming convention.

At $2000 I shelved the idea of ever owning one and instead turned to modding a custom version using a spare 503 body and parts from the KIN 5614 Select-O-matic II. And that was good enough for me for years.


Then in late May this year, I was contacted by @Dux of the rOtring Museum, who offered to help me acquire an actual ‘520’… for less than a fifth of Andrey’s original price (which sold, by the way). And so it came to be that I finally got to hold the mysterious ‘520’ in my hands.

Despite the shared design heritage with the KIN 5614, the ‘520’ stood out for its use of an incremental advance mechanism rather than a drop clutch. The knurling, body length and lead degree indicator were identical. However the button had a step to grip onto the plastic reserve tube. The ‘520’ also had a slightly brighter shade of burgundy compared to the modified 503’s.


Here’s a look at the disassembled parts. Another surprise for me was that the ‘520’ had a spring cushioned clutch. Yes, this quirk of the 50X and early 500 series seems to have started with the ‘520’! In comparison, KIN seems to have opted for simpler non-cushioned mechanisms for the Rapidomatic series. So, at the very least, it could be said that while the KIN 5614 was the starting point for both the Rapidomatic and rOtring 500 series, rOtring at least made an effort to be mechanically differentiated on the inside.


Here’s a quick look at the original ‘500’ series line-up… minus my ersatz 520. Again, it is interesting to see that the real ‘520’ had the rOtring logo centred on the hex barrel between the end of the knurled grip and the start of the steel clip… i.e. there was no plan for a number. Conversely, the 50X’s markings accounted for the numbering and was re-centered on the body. And then even later, when the numbering was changed to the current day ‘rOtring 500 / 0,5 mm’ styling, the logo stayed put and the additional text simply flowed on behind it.

Lastly here is a group shot of the 500, first generation 600 and 600G, along with some close-ups of their ‘no ring’ and ‘thin red ring’. Alongside the KIN family and earliest copycats from ALVIN, I think this closes my chapter on collecting rOtring.

19 Likes

Great report. :hugs:

Happy I was able help you get it.

6 Likes

I remember Andriy and his display; epic pieces all around, one rare oddity after the other. He was, I believe, the only account I ever saw listing an Automac E500 (for I think 1000$ of the time), a FC Tekagraph 9604 “Rund” (for 500$ in the late 2010’s), and oh so many other gems — a crown jewel like this rOtring was in the mix, of course.

He also had interesting Zippo lighters and nice Swiss-Army knives. Prices were never too low, but quality was always impeccable, and at the time he seemed one of the very few who could make the Asian stock and European buyers come into contact.

I miss the guy, and I truly am enraged at this mess of a world we live in, for having swallowed his Ebay outpost of progress in pencil collecting; I could not afford much, but I learned a lot from just looking at his listings. I wonder what has happened to him, and I hope one day, after we all find peace and serenity, he will pop up again, as if nothing had happened, to share an endless surplus of rare vintage specimens.

PS: that rOtring 520 is obviously fire, hands down.

3 Likes

Andrey was also the first seller I got Brazilian P200’s from.

2 Likes

Can you add a picture of the internals of the earliest 0.5 Rotring, Alvin, and KIN side-by-side?

1 Like


Here you go… I checked and grips and guts are 100% swappable across the bodies.

5 Likes

Thank you! Does the tip of that KIN unscrew from the grip? First gen does, as you know. I think KIN was the only brand ever to feature this but not 100% sure.

1 Like

I have one that does but it is a Made-in-China version.

Woah, that is crazy. The early Japan ones also have that feature and my China one does not. Is it possible yours has Japan grip+tip on the China body?

Anything is possible I guess but I got mine out of a sealed blister pack… And the quality of the knurling is a touch less refined.

1 Like

Great info. Thank you. Any idea what year your Japan made version in the pic is from?

Also, I am very surprised the KLIC-MATIC is such a faithful clone of the KIN.

Best guess for the Japan-made KIN is 1990s, because once Chartpak acquired KIN USA in 1999, they switched to the China-made blister packs.

1 Like

Nice article, well done!

Is Andrey the Russian seller who used to sell a lot of Koh-I-Knoor and A.W. Faber leadholders, including one antique set of leadholders listed at a super high price? If so, then I should have bought some Toison d’or leadolders from him.

That’s certainly possible. Andrey ran a veritable candystore of deadstock mechanical pencils…

1 Like