Pencils you regret buying

Not sure if this is regret or just disappointment but the grip on the Blick Premier is sub-par. I’ve never seen “slippery” knurling before.

The only MP I ever returned was the Ohto No-Knock, which I could only get the auto advance to work when the pencil was held at 90 degrees perpendicular to the paper.

2 Likes

Pilot S30, don’t like the “ballpoint feel” of it on paper

Faber Castell DS15L. The big plastic clutch combined with a very polished sliding lead pipe make for a very erratic and inconsistent lead advance. Almost unusable.

3 Likes

The first pencil I acquired on my collecting journey that I absolutely hated was the Faber-Castell TKfine Vario L. It forces me to grip so far away from the tip that I can barely control the pencil. And even then, it’s uncomfortable with the flared grip style.

A few more brutally disappointing pieces:

  • Pentel PS1045 — most slippery pencil on the planet, completely unusable, and mine had a crack the seller didn’t disclose
  • Pentel PG1505 — tip is miles long; my pressure points don’t even hit the knurled grip. Because of this, I never bothered to try and get a PG15, which is the most unholy combination of the PS1045 and PG1505.
  • Spoke 6explanation here, just a total disappointment
5 Likes

The PG15 is a nice pencil, but I would expect a little more heft. It feels a little too light when compared to the other very substantial Accugraphs. Reason: aluminium body.

3 Likes

Interesting. I do agree that the Blick Premier knurling is a bit smoother than I’d like, but I don’t have a particularly tough time maintaining a grip. But then… I don’t write with it for long periods. The click action is nicely tight, although mine was a bit gritty at first. It smoothed out after about a couple dozen clicks.

2 Likes

Wow, that is quite a low grip! Now I understand your gripes. I hold my pencils behind the nose cone and even about 5 mm back further from that. I sort of “auto adjust” with different nose cone grip length configurations, but I have been unhappy with a few pencils that I felt encouraged a grip a bit too far away from the tip.

Is the Pentel Graph Rocks pencil still being made today?

4 Likes

No. It was only available between 2019 & 2021. I still have a few sets for sale.

4 Likes

Interesting that all of your disappointing pieces stem from the way you hold your pencils. Totally fair. I’ve never experienced a pencil that I couldn’t grip/didn’t suit my grip style, so I guess that’s purely subjective.

I totally agree on the Spoke 6. I bought 2 when they initially released, and they’ve sat collecting dust since I bought them. Total downgrade from the aggressive knurling of the Spoke 4. I don’t think I’ve ever even used the Spoke 6’s to write a single stroke. I held them and could immediately tell how useless the knurling was.

1 Like

Might the new Zebra Rint be right for you?

2 Likes

solving the problem of being able to write neatly with total precision :nauseated_face:

Does it allow lower grip?